So I decided to follow up with green eyeshadow. I just applied the medium shade of Bourjois Smoky Eyes trio in 08 Vert Trendy, over my lids. I found it was overwhelming the eyeliner a little, so I swept the lightest shade over the whole thing, and applied that shade in the inner corners as well.
I followed up with a second coat of eyeliner. I love this eyeliner! I finished with Estee Lauder's Double Wear Zero Smudge mascara.